Barriers to Indigenous Wealth
On average, the wealth gap between Native Americans and white Americans could be described as more of a chasm. Here’s a look at some of the barriers that have prevented Indigenous communities from thriving financially.
High income and wealth are difficult to achieve for many Native Americans in the U.S. Consider these statistics:
- The median household income for Native Americans was 60% of median white household income before the COVID-19 pandemic, and estimates are it's only gotten worse, especially for Native American women.
- The average Native American household has 8 cents of wealth for every dollar of wealth for the average white American household.
- As of 2017, 22% of Native Americans were living in poverty compared with 8% of white Americans.
- The homeownership rate was 51% among Native Americans, compared with 73% for white non-Hispanic Americans in 2019.
When looking at statistics, it's important to recognize that Native Americans are not a monolithic group. There are hundreds of tribes, nations and bands, each with unique languages and cultures. We can look at the numbers in aggregate because of the shared history of trauma, oppression, displacement and cultural erasure in the U.S. that continues to block Native American financial growth and stability.
Here are some of the factors that have inhibited Native Americans' access to building financial wealth and passing it on to future generations.
Systematic colonization began more than 500 years ago, with the arrival of European settlers who claimed land for themselves that had already been occupied by Indigenous people for centuries.
The settlers violently forced their way onto the land, displacing Indigenous people. The English claimed all the land east of the Mississippi after winning the French and Indian War of 1754-1763. Colonizers enslaved Native Americans who were allies of the losing side.
Colonizers also brought with them diseases for which Indigenous people had no immunity. By some estimates, illness killed as much as 90% of Native American populations.
That loss of life and land has been putting Native Americans at a severe financial disadvantage ever since colonizers arrived.
Forced Relocation and Genocide
As the United States government formed, the takeover of Native American lands continued. The settlers drew borders and developed land for individual economic gain, building financial wealth they could pass down to their future generations.
Contrary to popular belief, Native Americans understood land ownership and owned land themselves, although there were, and in many ways still are, significant cultural differences between the Native American and settlers' approach, and among tribes in how land and resources were managed, how value was assigned, and whether the benefit was communal or for individuals.
Many white settlers believed they were entitled to the land, and the presence of Native Americans interfered with their plans. So, the settlers took the land, often violently, burning down houses and even committing mass murder. President Andrew Jackson referred to this as the "Indian Problem." To make room for the settlers, and their lucrative industries such as cotton farming, Jackson signed the Indian Removal Act in 1830 giving the federal government the authority to take Native American land in the east in exchange for land west of the Mississippi.
Native Americans from different tribes were marched thousands of miles, many in chains with little or no food, to what the federal government had designated "Indian Territory." About 3,000 Native Americans died of starvation and disease along what would become known as the Trail of Tears.
When colonization began, the North American Indigenous population was estimated at 5 million to 15 million. By 1900, about 400 years later, the population dropped to fewer than 238,000.
Reservations and Forced Assimilation
In 1851, the Indian Appropriations Act created the reservation system. Tribes were moved to land they were told they could farm, but it was often on unwanted land, where nothing could grow. Native communities struggled to maintain their culture. Tribes were forced to wear non-Native clothes, cut their hair, abandon their language and give up their spiritual beliefs.
The Dawes Act of 1887 further reduced the amount of land in Native American control. The law divided the tribes' land into tracts that would be allotted to individual Native Americans. Once the allotments were made to tribal members, the remaining land was sold to white Americans. As a result, Native Americans lost an estimated 86 million acres, or 62%, of their land.
Trust Land and Limited Property Rights
Native American reservations are sovereign nations that aren't subject to federal laws, but the federal government holds much of the tribal lands in trust, hampering the wealth-building potential of the land for the tribe and its members. In many cases, Native Americans can't build equity and pass it on to their children. They can't take loans against their property, sell it or develop it in the same way private property owners who hold the property title can.
There is debate about whether individual ownership or communal ownership would most benefit a tribe, but the existing system doesn't give tribes the choice, leaving many out of a common method of building wealth.
Lack of Access to Banking and Affordable Credit
An estimated 16.3% of Native American households are unbanked (don't use banks or credit unions), representing the lowest rate of banked households in the country, according to the National Indian Council on Aging.
Often, people are unbanked because of poor credit history or distrust of the banking system. Without a traditional bank, they must rely on non-traditional financial service providers to cash paychecks, take out money orders to pay bills, and borrow against upcoming paychecks. These services come with high fees and interest rates.
Native Americans who live on reservations often have the additional challenge of traveling long distances to financial institutions and ATMs, and spotty internet access that makes online banking difficult.
To fill the void left by traditional banks, some Native Americans have built their own banks and credit unions to meet the needs of the communities they serve.
According to the National Indian Council on Aging, there are 30 Native American and Alaska Native banks and credit unions in the U.S. working to provide financial assistance and banking services to communities and tribal-owned businesses.
The history of violence and stolen land set the starting line for financial health and wealth farther away for many Native Americans. Colonizers and the federal government created mechanisms to give white Americans a head start in a world that was new to them and forcibly removed Indigenous people. By controlling the borders and holding land in trust, the federal government has retained control of Native American populations, despite their sovereign status.
- Money as Medicine: Edgar Villanueva on Closing the Racial Wealth Gap
- Native Americans and the Racial Wealth Divide
- Native American Women Lose Nearly $1 Million to the Pay Gap Over Their Careers — and COVID-19 Could Make the Disparity Worse
- Native Households Make 8 Cents for Every Dollar a White Household Has
- Systemic Inequality: Displacement, Exclusion, and Segregation
- Native Americans in Colonial America
- When Native Americans Were Slaughtered in the Name of 'Civilization'
- Ownership Structure of Tribal Land Exacts a Multibillion-Dollar Penalty
- Native Households Have Highest Unbanked Percentage